My father died from pancreatic cancer in 2016. He was 54. I don't think I'm ever going to get over it. Otherwise healthy guy starts not feeling great, goes to the doctor, gets misdiagnosed a few times. After a few months of that gets told that it's pancreatic cancer and he has 10-12 months. 15 months later he was gone. When I see news like this it gives me such hope for other people.
Misdiagnosis is very common with pancreatic cancer, it seems. My mum was complaining about stomach pains and sickness for a long time before they finally tested her for pancreatic cancer; before that, they had all sorts of theories about what it was, including tropical sprue. By the time she knew it was cancer, she was stage 4 with months to live. Thankfully, chemo kept her alive just long enough to meet her grandson, and also for assisted dying laws that had just passed in Victoria, Australia.
Hope that one day no one else has to go through what we did.
My mom died of cancer, and last month represented the point where I’ve lived longer without her than with. There is no “getting over it.” But there is living with it. It’s brutal and it’s unfair. But like you, these kinds of stories make me optimistic that future people won’t have to go through that, or this.
Your message is so relatable - sorry to hear it. My father died of pancreatic cancer too. It was in 2006 and he was 56. Almost the same story - he always seemed so strong and healthy but started complaining of stomach pain. Doctors misdiagnosed him several times with indigestion, stomach ulcers, and even depression at one point. Eventually though, after going back enough times, they eventually diagnosed him with pancreatic cancer in May of 2006 - he died the following November. It's 20 years ago this month and I still miss him like it was yesterday.
If there's one thing I hope comes from all the AI discoveries that are predicted to happen is that there's finally a cure for all types of cancer.
I lost my mom to pancreatic cancer in 2016 as well. The doctors thought it was a gall bladder issue, sent her for a scan before the surgery, and realized it was pancreatic cancer instead. She died 5 months later.
Ten years later, and I've decided it's time to read the last book she ever gave me.
I really hope we'll see a cure for this disease soon.
I dread pancreatic cancer and dementia more than other diseases.
Pancreatic cancer feels like a horrible fate: long enough to contemplate your own mortality and see the end with no real hope of avoiding your fate.
I do know someone who survived a Whipple and lived for a decade after (he was a health fanatic, and paid careful attention to his body, so it was detected early because he didn't let go till he got a diagnosis); succumbing to an unrelated disease, but I hope that there's more hope for people than is currently the case.
What are the symptoms in the early stages? Just some belly ache now or then? Or something more severe?
I’ve had digestive problems for years. But recently, it’s gotten worse. Blood tests, urine+stool tests, and a colonoscopy all came back normal. Lately, I’ve been experiencing severe pain when lying down and can only sleep sitting up.
My doctor thinks it might be a mechanical issue with my spine and told me to just take ibuprofen for the pain and inflammation.
The problem with abdominal pain is that it’s impossible for me to tell which organ the pain is coming from. Kidney? Liver? Intestine? Spine? It's very frightening and I don't know what to do.
Often, no symptoms in the early stages. By the time you notice something's wrong, it's likely too late. My dad was at stage three when they caught his and they told him He was lucky. Most people don't notice anything wrong and he just had a minor thing that on surprise, he would have mentioned to a doctor.
Even when symptoms are noticed, most symptoms that people have can be any one of a number of things. Go look for constipation, then look up each symptom individually and see what all it can map to. Pretty much every symptom of the very common constipation is also the only symptom you'll see of heart attack, liver cancer, liver disease, appendicitis, pancreatic cancer, pretty much anything goes wrong in the rib cage...
Spine would be the only exception. I don't think Spine ever manifests quite that way. On the other hand, my leg pain turned out to be a tumor on the spine. Thankfully it wasn't cancer.
Really, the best advice I can get is pay attention to what you feel like normally. If something's unusual, get to a doctor. Most people who go to the ER for a heart attack symptom are not having a heart attack. We could save a lot of lives, and I mean a lot of lives, if more people would be going to the emergency room for heart attack symptoms even though most people who don't go to the ER for such symptoms are correct they're not having a heart attack and don't need to be there.
Yep, that tracks. My relative who got a Whipple and survived paid close attention to his body and didn't give up till he got the answer. It pays to be healthy and health-conscious it seems.
My friend died of this a bit under year ago. She was a fighter and struggled through.
The first warning sign for her was jaundice, so she took on a kind of sallow (yellow/brown) complexion. However, looking back I noticed that before diagnosis, and never connected it.
Two other things which may signal trouble are energy crashes and weight fluctuations. I know two people who had trouble with this recently. In one case, it turned out to be thyroid cancer, and he had to push for diagnosis, and nag the medics to get something done. He seems to be okay now (touch wood), but take note of this.
I agree about abdominal pain. Hard to know what causes it. Back and even chest pain don't always stem from expected causes. (People assume chest pain is heart trouble. It can be but there are other things.)
Try not to blame the GP. Misdiagnosis is the norm, and exactly why survival stats are so dismal.
Pancreatic cancer is the original zebra disease -- it's so rare that it would be irresponsible to go looking for it before ruling out all of the more common things it looks like.
Sorry for your loss. My mother in law passed away from this horrible disease in her 50s. She was diagnosed early enough to get Whipple procedure but with this kind of cancer almost nothing helped about 15y ago, not sure it if changed even a little.
My mom died of pancreatic cancer in 2016 too. Also misdiagnosed and told she had IBS. Cancer was only diagnosed when the pain got very intense and she was given 3 months. She died 10 months later, at the age of 63 having gone through hell. Not a day passes that I don’t think of her. I feel your pain and hope others will not have to go through the same thing as our parents did.
Father in law, 2015. He was 72. Exact same story, except they wanted to put him on antipsychotics and thought he was a drug seeker. Diagnosed finally, thanks to my wife's persistence in fighting the medical establishment, and he died in 3 months.
That disease is the absolute worst and I'm really happy to see this progress.
Does a misdiagnosis really make a difference with this deadly disease? It is my understanding that by the time any noticeable symptoms appear, it is already too late to stop it from progressing.
It can be frustrating to not know the true cause of the symptoms, but only a cure (this trial seems to show promise) will offer any real hope.
Sorry for your loss. My mom passed from pancreatic cancer in the spring of this year. If the grief decay continues at this linear rate I'm afraid I'll be saying the same thing in ten years.
And totally agree about these giving hope. Especially for me and the rest of her lineage.
My dad died in 1994, when I was a few weeks from turning 16. I think most people carry the loss of significant relationships like parents for the rest of their lives. It isn't a negative thing, it's part of living.
One of the more helpful things I saw somewhere was something along the lines of accepting each loss as its own thing. Your relationship with your father may have similar intensity as a spouse, but it's a different thing. The things you deal with on one situation may not matter in another, and so on.
My wife, a marathon runner and all-around amazing person, died in 2016 five months after diagnosis at age 36. I’ve written about it here before, but the highest way I can think to honor her is to really, truly appreciate the gift of every single day that you’ve got. Life feels like inertia, that tomorrow will always be there, that you will see your plans through. It’s an illusion.
It will probably take my lifetime or more to make more than incremental progress on this disease, but I welcome every step.
My favorite uncle died from pancreatic cancer when I was a teenager. I remember at the time I quickly looked up the survivability rates of pancreatic cancer and was immediately sad to see it was nearly zero [1].
For the next few months, there was a roller coaster of hearing about his new treatments, sometimes seeming effective where we would convince ourselves that he's going to get better, only for him to take a turn for the worse. This kept happening until, of course, he died. I was sad he was dead but the combination of the cancer and the chemo seemed really miserable so I was at least happy he wasn't in pain anymore.
This happened around the time Patrick Swayze died from pancreatic cancer, and a bit before Steve Jobs, and it was at least a little reassuring that this disease didn't spare even obscenely wealthy people. I hope we figure out better treatments for it, and this seems promising.
[1] At least when caught late, which it often is and was for him.
Worth noting that the cancer Jobs had is _very_ different from the kind Swayze had.
Jobs had a PanNET tumor[0]. That's the pancreatic cancer you "want". The survival rates are incomparable (iirc localized PanNET survival rate is around 95%!). Jobs chose woowoo bullshit over science, until it was too late. With his money he would have almost certainly been in the surviving group.
Edit to add:
Generally when people refer to "pancreatic cancer", they are almost exclusively referring to Adenocarcinoma - the deadly one. That's what Swayze had.
Jobs delayed surgery of a slow-growing cancer by 9 months. We can't know for certain that decision contributed to his death. He may have been in that 5%. It's a lot easier to pull the black marble out of a bag of 20 than it sounds.
Pancreatic cancer is almost always caught late, because the main indicator is that it's spread to other places. Very rarely, you'll get jaundice from it and then it can be caught early. Survivability in those cases are still really low.
Right. The jaundice is due to obstruction of the CBT (common bile duct). The CBT carries bilirubin (dead red blood cells). Excess bilirubin shows up as jaundice.
The earlier one's CBT is blocked, the better, as it results in earlier diagnosis.
> ...it was at least a little reassuring that this disease didn't spare even obscenely wealthy people.
The obscenely wealthy people eat mostly the same food as obscenely unwealthy people do. From [1], one can conclude that it goes for 3000 years now, probably longer.
I was trying to figure out what the actual intervention was, and what clinical trial this is from based on the extremely limited information, and have not been able to yet.
In the mean time, here's 25 clinical trials for oncolytic viral therapies for pancreatic cancer:
Adenoviruses are very easy to make with custom contents, and are used for many many purposes. However they rarely make it all the way to become a therapy in practice.
It's always fascinating what hits the front page of HN when it comes to bio!
I'm getting a 403 error, possibly denied for my region. Can you tell me how many were in the trial. 3 successes is great(any success is good), but without knowing how many were in the trial I can't get very excited.
Edit: The main article identifies an adenovirus that has been modified to replicate primarily in cancerous cells.
"The only cancer-killing virus that has been approved by the Food and Drug Administration in the US is T-VEC, a genetically modified herpes simplex virus that is injected directly into melanoma tumours, causing the cells to rupture and die."
My father died a year ago from PSP. He was 82. I miss him every day, even though when he died I knew it was time as he was really suffering.
I felt my missing him was odd as he didn't die that young. But reading all these stories of people who lost parents or relatives to pancreatic cancer and seeing how much they miss them years later... maybe it's normal to miss a parent even if their time had come.
I lost my dad, who was one of my best friends, to pancreatic cancer in 2007 at the age of 62. As a psychologist, he saved saved so many people's lives, many of whom have let me know directly. It just isn't fair. He found out about it because the tumor showed up on a CT scan they did for a kidney stone. He was otherwise healthy. It is still so painful to think about how much I miss him and all of the important life events he missed. I'm grateful for the time I got with him and especially that we had such a meaningful relationship and that I was with him when he died. I sincerely hope this proves out and saves lives.
Very early results, but it's exciting stuff. I am less confident in this specific trial working out than I am in some therapies in this field making significant progress in the next few years. (As usual, I am reminded how terribly slow research is for people that need treatments now.)
So many impacted by cancer in this thread, I've also been in the position where you feel powerless when someone close to you is diagnosed. I try to take opportunities like this to remind people that there are some types of cancer (and other conditions) that you can help other people with through a bone marrow transplant.
Cancers like leukemia, melanoma, lymphoma and conditions like aplastic anemia, immune, autoimmune disorders can be treated by infusing the patient with compatible bone marrow stem cells from a donor. Finding a compatible donor can be difficult, on average in the general population its on the order of 1:10,000 to find a match. For that reason there's a registry that people can submit a cheek swab to. In my case I joined the registry about 15 years ago when someone in my extended friend circle had leukemia. A swab drive was organized to find her a donor, which eventually happened and she wound up beating it. I didn't match her but a few years ago I matched another patient and wound up donating.
In the US the registry is National Marrow Donor Program. Signup on their website and they will send you a free swab kit.
A few years ago my father died from ampullary adenocarcinoma, a close (but rarer) cousin to pancreatic adenocarcinoma. It's such sweet sorrow to read about this now. I hope this goes all the way through trials and saves many lives.
This article very much reads like AI, but it's great that we're making progress towards improving survival rates for pancreatic cancer. Hopefully there's gonna be a lot more of that stuff coming.
In 2024 my close friend was diagnosed in June and they passed away in February, despite best-in-class care in a first world country. A cure cannot come fast enough.
Is it normal to not report how many people received the treatment and just report the number of successes? Is this better than placebo or doing nothing?
It sounds like it might've been the first three people to receive the treatment at all. 15 more are going to be given higher doses next to hunt for an optimum level.
I think with trials involving experimental life saving treatment for terminal illnesses, doing things like control groups and placebos isn't considered particularly ethical, since you'd be giving false hope to someone who is knocking on death's door.
It's normal for a Phase 1 trial, which evaluates safety and dosing on a small number of participants. If the drug passes, more extensive trials will be done.
Why test against a placebo when you can test against death?
Although not 100%, almost all terminal patients will die. If you select your test group well so they are very likely to die, then you improve the information you get from the test, favor the class of patients who are most likely to benefit from the treatment and least likely to be harmed by it overall.
Neither does this method as far as we know yet. The article is even good at spelling it out at the beginning. Literally every test is for something that might work, otherwise we wouldn't run it in the first piece.
Perhaps if the new cancer therapies being developed are found to be most effective on cancers caught early, it will spawn a renewed effort to create tests that could be added to the regular annual checkup regimen.
Maybe, but that's of questionable value. There are a lot of cancers that are known to grow for a while and then just die off for unknown reasons. In the early stages, it sometimes is the best thing to say. Well, we're going to watch this and see if it gets even worse.
Notice that I said sometimes above. Sometimes the earlier we catch it, the earlier we treat it, the better. But sometimes not. See your doctor and hope your doctor is up with the latest research.
Aee there good filters? Not really. Symptoms can be nonexistant or nonspecific until it's too late. And the only recommended screening is an endoscopic ultrasound, but it's not really indicated except for people who are 'high risk'.
'High risk' in this case means someone who has had 2 relatives develop the disease - otherwise it's not recommended due to the risk of false positives and everything that comes with that.
I only know all this because my mother died of the disease.
My father died from pancreatic cancer in 2016. He was 54. I don't think I'm ever going to get over it. Otherwise healthy guy starts not feeling great, goes to the doctor, gets misdiagnosed a few times. After a few months of that gets told that it's pancreatic cancer and he has 10-12 months. 15 months later he was gone. When I see news like this it gives me such hope for other people.
Sorry for your loss.
Misdiagnosis is very common with pancreatic cancer, it seems. My mum was complaining about stomach pains and sickness for a long time before they finally tested her for pancreatic cancer; before that, they had all sorts of theories about what it was, including tropical sprue. By the time she knew it was cancer, she was stage 4 with months to live. Thankfully, chemo kept her alive just long enough to meet her grandson, and also for assisted dying laws that had just passed in Victoria, Australia.
Hope that one day no one else has to go through what we did.
The misdiagnosis is what makes it so deadly unfortunately :(
My mom died of cancer, and last month represented the point where I’ve lived longer without her than with. There is no “getting over it.” But there is living with it. It’s brutal and it’s unfair. But like you, these kinds of stories make me optimistic that future people won’t have to go through that, or this.
Your message is so relatable - sorry to hear it. My father died of pancreatic cancer too. It was in 2006 and he was 56. Almost the same story - he always seemed so strong and healthy but started complaining of stomach pain. Doctors misdiagnosed him several times with indigestion, stomach ulcers, and even depression at one point. Eventually though, after going back enough times, they eventually diagnosed him with pancreatic cancer in May of 2006 - he died the following November. It's 20 years ago this month and I still miss him like it was yesterday. If there's one thing I hope comes from all the AI discoveries that are predicted to happen is that there's finally a cure for all types of cancer.
I lost my mom to pancreatic cancer in 2016 as well. The doctors thought it was a gall bladder issue, sent her for a scan before the surgery, and realized it was pancreatic cancer instead. She died 5 months later.
Ten years later, and I've decided it's time to read the last book she ever gave me.
I really hope we'll see a cure for this disease soon.
I'm sorry for your loss.
I dread pancreatic cancer and dementia more than other diseases.
Pancreatic cancer feels like a horrible fate: long enough to contemplate your own mortality and see the end with no real hope of avoiding your fate.
I do know someone who survived a Whipple and lived for a decade after (he was a health fanatic, and paid careful attention to his body, so it was detected early because he didn't let go till he got a diagnosis); succumbing to an unrelated disease, but I hope that there's more hope for people than is currently the case.
What are the symptoms in the early stages? Just some belly ache now or then? Or something more severe?
I’ve had digestive problems for years. But recently, it’s gotten worse. Blood tests, urine+stool tests, and a colonoscopy all came back normal. Lately, I’ve been experiencing severe pain when lying down and can only sleep sitting up.
My doctor thinks it might be a mechanical issue with my spine and told me to just take ibuprofen for the pain and inflammation.
The problem with abdominal pain is that it’s impossible for me to tell which organ the pain is coming from. Kidney? Liver? Intestine? Spine? It's very frightening and I don't know what to do.
Often, no symptoms in the early stages. By the time you notice something's wrong, it's likely too late. My dad was at stage three when they caught his and they told him He was lucky. Most people don't notice anything wrong and he just had a minor thing that on surprise, he would have mentioned to a doctor.
Even when symptoms are noticed, most symptoms that people have can be any one of a number of things. Go look for constipation, then look up each symptom individually and see what all it can map to. Pretty much every symptom of the very common constipation is also the only symptom you'll see of heart attack, liver cancer, liver disease, appendicitis, pancreatic cancer, pretty much anything goes wrong in the rib cage...
Spine would be the only exception. I don't think Spine ever manifests quite that way. On the other hand, my leg pain turned out to be a tumor on the spine. Thankfully it wasn't cancer.
Really, the best advice I can get is pay attention to what you feel like normally. If something's unusual, get to a doctor. Most people who go to the ER for a heart attack symptom are not having a heart attack. We could save a lot of lives, and I mean a lot of lives, if more people would be going to the emergency room for heart attack symptoms even though most people who don't go to the ER for such symptoms are correct they're not having a heart attack and don't need to be there.
Yep, that tracks. My relative who got a Whipple and survived paid close attention to his body and didn't give up till he got the answer. It pays to be healthy and health-conscious it seems.
I asked a friend of mine who was dying of pancreatic cancer what the first signs were of trouble and he replied, "Peeing colors."
My friend died of this a bit under year ago. She was a fighter and struggled through.
The first warning sign for her was jaundice, so she took on a kind of sallow (yellow/brown) complexion. However, looking back I noticed that before diagnosis, and never connected it.
Two other things which may signal trouble are energy crashes and weight fluctuations. I know two people who had trouble with this recently. In one case, it turned out to be thyroid cancer, and he had to push for diagnosis, and nag the medics to get something done. He seems to be okay now (touch wood), but take note of this.
I agree about abdominal pain. Hard to know what causes it. Back and even chest pain don't always stem from expected causes. (People assume chest pain is heart trouble. It can be but there are other things.)
I think the Galieri test screens for pancreatic cancer as one of its data points plus other types of cancer as well.
Could be a good next step for you.
https://www.galleri.com/cancers/pancreatic
My dad died in April from it. He died just 5 weeks after the diagnosis. He was 67. I still cannot believe it!
When I tried to research I very quickly realized there is really nothing you can do. Maybe this does give people hope!
Same for my uncle, also this spring. It also happened so fast and was instantly hopeless.
Similar to my mother.
In her 50s. Kept relatively healthy for the previous 30 years. Misdiagnosed repeatedly by a trusted GP. Had so much life to live. It was so unfair.
News like this is so heartening.
Very sorry for your loss.
Try not to blame the GP. Misdiagnosis is the norm, and exactly why survival stats are so dismal.
Pancreatic cancer is the original zebra disease -- it's so rare that it would be irresponsible to go looking for it before ruling out all of the more common things it looks like.
Sorry for your loss. My mother in law passed away from this horrible disease in her 50s. She was diagnosed early enough to get Whipple procedure but with this kind of cancer almost nothing helped about 15y ago, not sure it if changed even a little.
My mom died of pancreatic cancer in 2016 too. Also misdiagnosed and told she had IBS. Cancer was only diagnosed when the pain got very intense and she was given 3 months. She died 10 months later, at the age of 63 having gone through hell. Not a day passes that I don’t think of her. I feel your pain and hope others will not have to go through the same thing as our parents did.
Father in law, 2015. He was 72. Exact same story, except they wanted to put him on antipsychotics and thought he was a drug seeker. Diagnosed finally, thanks to my wife's persistence in fighting the medical establishment, and he died in 3 months.
That disease is the absolute worst and I'm really happy to see this progress.
Does a misdiagnosis really make a difference with this deadly disease? It is my understanding that by the time any noticeable symptoms appear, it is already too late to stop it from progressing.
It can be frustrating to not know the true cause of the symptoms, but only a cure (this trial seems to show promise) will offer any real hope.
> I don't think I'm ever going to get over it.
Sorry for your loss. My mom passed from pancreatic cancer in the spring of this year. If the grief decay continues at this linear rate I'm afraid I'll be saying the same thing in ten years.
And totally agree about these giving hope. Especially for me and the rest of her lineage.
My dad died in 1994, when I was a few weeks from turning 16. I think most people carry the loss of significant relationships like parents for the rest of their lives. It isn't a negative thing, it's part of living.
One of the more helpful things I saw somewhere was something along the lines of accepting each loss as its own thing. Your relationship with your father may have similar intensity as a spouse, but it's a different thing. The things you deal with on one situation may not matter in another, and so on.
My wife, a marathon runner and all-around amazing person, died in 2016 five months after diagnosis at age 36. I’ve written about it here before, but the highest way I can think to honor her is to really, truly appreciate the gift of every single day that you’ve got. Life feels like inertia, that tomorrow will always be there, that you will see your plans through. It’s an illusion.
It will probably take my lifetime or more to make more than incremental progress on this disease, but I welcome every step.
I'm sorry for your loss. My dad just got diagnosed.
My favorite uncle died from pancreatic cancer when I was a teenager. I remember at the time I quickly looked up the survivability rates of pancreatic cancer and was immediately sad to see it was nearly zero [1].
For the next few months, there was a roller coaster of hearing about his new treatments, sometimes seeming effective where we would convince ourselves that he's going to get better, only for him to take a turn for the worse. This kept happening until, of course, he died. I was sad he was dead but the combination of the cancer and the chemo seemed really miserable so I was at least happy he wasn't in pain anymore.
This happened around the time Patrick Swayze died from pancreatic cancer, and a bit before Steve Jobs, and it was at least a little reassuring that this disease didn't spare even obscenely wealthy people. I hope we figure out better treatments for it, and this seems promising.
[1] At least when caught late, which it often is and was for him.
Worth noting that the cancer Jobs had is _very_ different from the kind Swayze had.
Jobs had a PanNET tumor[0]. That's the pancreatic cancer you "want". The survival rates are incomparable (iirc localized PanNET survival rate is around 95%!). Jobs chose woowoo bullshit over science, until it was too late. With his money he would have almost certainly been in the surviving group.
Edit to add: Generally when people refer to "pancreatic cancer", they are almost exclusively referring to Adenocarcinoma - the deadly one. That's what Swayze had.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pancreatic_neuroendocrine_tumo...
Jobs delayed surgery of a slow-growing cancer by 9 months. We can't know for certain that decision contributed to his death. He may have been in that 5%. It's a lot easier to pull the black marble out of a bag of 20 than it sounds.
Pancreatic cancer is almost always caught late, because the main indicator is that it's spread to other places. Very rarely, you'll get jaundice from it and then it can be caught early. Survivability in those cases are still really low.
Right. The jaundice is due to obstruction of the CBT (common bile duct). The CBT carries bilirubin (dead red blood cells). Excess bilirubin shows up as jaundice.
The earlier one's CBT is blocked, the better, as it results in earlier diagnosis.
Yeah, I can't remember how they found out about his, but it was already late enough to where death was basically a foregone conclusion.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uncd7SvT94c (pharaohs eat same food as the lower classes of society, judging from the teeth wear and decay)
I don't think it was true in Europe, where knights and Lords were eating way more meat than peasants for example.
I was trying to figure out what the actual intervention was, and what clinical trial this is from based on the extremely limited information, and have not been able to yet.
In the mean time, here's 25 clinical trials for oncolytic viral therapies for pancreatic cancer:
https://clinicaltrials.gov/search?cond=Pancreatic%20Cancer&i...
And here's a review article on the general concept from the lead physician-researcher in this article:
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6186423/
Adenoviruses are very easy to make with custom contents, and are used for many many purposes. However they rarely make it all the way to become a therapy in practice.
It's always fascinating what hits the front page of HN when it comes to bio!
Here is the page for the trial: https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT06693986
The contact there is Edward Greeno, the same oncologist named in UMN's coverage: https://discoverymag.umn.edu/stories/when-cancer-therapy-goe...
I'm getting a 403 error, possibly denied for my region. Can you tell me how many were in the trial. 3 successes is great(any success is good), but without knowing how many were in the trial I can't get very excited.
Kurzgesagt has mentioned oncolytic viruses in their recent videos.
This general discussion of the human virome mentions Newcastle disease and Reovirus:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=SbvAaDN1bpE
A full episode followed on a biologist who injected her tumor with Measles:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0NY2gAftzJE
Edit: The main article identifies an adenovirus that has been modified to replicate primarily in cancerous cells.
"The only cancer-killing virus that has been approved by the Food and Drug Administration in the US is T-VEC, a genetically modified herpes simplex virus that is injected directly into melanoma tumours, causing the cells to rupture and die."
My father died a year ago from PSP. He was 82. I miss him every day, even though when he died I knew it was time as he was really suffering.
I felt my missing him was odd as he didn't die that young. But reading all these stories of people who lost parents or relatives to pancreatic cancer and seeing how much they miss them years later... maybe it's normal to miss a parent even if their time had come.
Parents have such an impact on their children.
I lost my dad, who was one of my best friends, to pancreatic cancer in 2007 at the age of 62. As a psychologist, he saved saved so many people's lives, many of whom have let me know directly. It just isn't fair. He found out about it because the tumor showed up on a CT scan they did for a kidney stone. He was otherwise healthy. It is still so painful to think about how much I miss him and all of the important life events he missed. I'm grateful for the time I got with him and especially that we had such a meaningful relationship and that I was with him when he died. I sincerely hope this proves out and saves lives.
Relevant recent paper from the lead researcher: https://doi.org/10.1158/1535-7163.MCT-25-1231
Very early results, but it's exciting stuff. I am less confident in this specific trial working out than I am in some therapies in this field making significant progress in the next few years. (As usual, I am reminded how terribly slow research is for people that need treatments now.)
So many impacted by cancer in this thread, I've also been in the position where you feel powerless when someone close to you is diagnosed. I try to take opportunities like this to remind people that there are some types of cancer (and other conditions) that you can help other people with through a bone marrow transplant.
Cancers like leukemia, melanoma, lymphoma and conditions like aplastic anemia, immune, autoimmune disorders can be treated by infusing the patient with compatible bone marrow stem cells from a donor. Finding a compatible donor can be difficult, on average in the general population its on the order of 1:10,000 to find a match. For that reason there's a registry that people can submit a cheek swab to. In my case I joined the registry about 15 years ago when someone in my extended friend circle had leukemia. A swab drive was organized to find her a donor, which eventually happened and she wound up beating it. I didn't match her but a few years ago I matched another patient and wound up donating.
In the US the registry is National Marrow Donor Program. Signup on their website and they will send you a free swab kit.
https://www.nmdp.org/
An excellent source, Kurzgesagt covered the use of virology to cure cancer recently: https://youtu.be/0NY2gAftzJE?si=yeYfT4yc8_ffGmDD
How do they even make money? I love them but I worry they're going to disappear.
Gates Foundation.
That video has 21 million views and you are asking how they even make money?
They make money from ads.
A few years ago my father died from ampullary adenocarcinoma, a close (but rarer) cousin to pancreatic adenocarcinoma. It's such sweet sorrow to read about this now. I hope this goes all the way through trials and saves many lives.
On topic, a very inspirational last lecture by Randy Pausch a professor at Carnegie Mellon who was dying of pancreatic cancer
https://youtu.be/ayPMfopCe1g?is=XaFVwNeWlthozmj4
A site that actually functions:
https://www.newscientist.com/article/2528235-pancreatic-canc...
A link with no subscription wall: https://archive.ph/2Et0x
yes! what's with the original link? I thought my internet was down or browser malfunctioned. No response for 20 seconds or so.
I‘m getting 403/forbidden here.
This article very much reads like AI, but it's great that we're making progress towards improving survival rates for pancreatic cancer. Hopefully there's gonna be a lot more of that stuff coming.
In 2024 my close friend was diagnosed in June and they passed away in February, despite best-in-class care in a first world country. A cure cannot come fast enough.
Is it normal to not report how many people received the treatment and just report the number of successes? Is this better than placebo or doing nothing?
It sounds like it might've been the first three people to receive the treatment at all. 15 more are going to be given higher doses next to hunt for an optimum level.
I think with trials involving experimental life saving treatment for terminal illnesses, doing things like control groups and placebos isn't considered particularly ethical, since you'd be giving false hope to someone who is knocking on death's door.
It's normal for a Phase 1 trial, which evaluates safety and dosing on a small number of participants. If the drug passes, more extensive trials will be done.
Why test against a placebo when you can test against death?
Although not 100%, almost all terminal patients will die. If you select your test group well so they are very likely to die, then you improve the information you get from the test, favor the class of patients who are most likely to benefit from the treatment and least likely to be harmed by it overall.
Because placebo also helps. You're not checking vs doing nothing, but vs pretending you're doing something.
Placebo does not cure pancreatic cancer. It is inhumane to test placebo for something that might work
Neither does this method as far as we know yet. The article is even good at spelling it out at the beginning. Literally every test is for something that might work, otherwise we wouldn't run it in the first piece.
Usually it’s experiment vs standard of care
Placebo doesn't do much for advanced pancreatic cancer, no matter how optimistic you feel about it.
tell that those terminal patients. i'm sure they like to hear that placebo helps them.
Perhaps if the new cancer therapies being developed are found to be most effective on cancers caught early, it will spawn a renewed effort to create tests that could be added to the regular annual checkup regimen.
Maybe, but that's of questionable value. There are a lot of cancers that are known to grow for a while and then just die off for unknown reasons. In the early stages, it sometimes is the best thing to say. Well, we're going to watch this and see if it gets even worse.
Notice that I said sometimes above. Sometimes the earlier we catch it, the earlier we treat it, the better. But sometimes not. See your doctor and hope your doctor is up with the latest research.
Maybe someone could invent some sort of machine that could test for hundred for diseases a with a small sample of blood...
Question - isnt part of the problem it spreads before its caught? Are there good filters to find it?
Typically yes. So the real question is, can this treatment treat it after it is spread?
If someone could come up with a good way to catch before it starts spreading, that would be even better, but I'm not aware of any progress on that.
Aee there good filters? Not really. Symptoms can be nonexistant or nonspecific until it's too late. And the only recommended screening is an endoscopic ultrasound, but it's not really indicated except for people who are 'high risk'.
'High risk' in this case means someone who has had 2 relatives develop the disease - otherwise it's not recommended due to the risk of false positives and everything that comes with that.
I only know all this because my mother died of the disease.
> The latest report adds follow-up, not a final verdict
Is there a "label" for this type of AI slop writing? I see it A LOT in most of my sessions with the format:
[Some positive assertion of something that is], not [something that is not/doesn't hold].
That's a sure sign of something being AI written, and I battle to make AIs avoid it because it doesn't add anything of value.
The best way to win the battle is to reject AI writing entirely. Calling it out (like you did here) is good.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3xY6Ffy_wE
I remember hearing about this way back in 2014. Science moves slowly.
Still no cure for... wait, what?